Billy Joel looked out over a room full of college students and picked a hand.
A young freshman stood up. He said his favourite Billy Joel song was “New York State of Mind.” Then he asked something nobody in the room expected.
“I was wondering if I could play it with you. I would accompany you, that is.”
For a second, Billy Joel just looked at him.
The kid in the perfect seat
It was January 30, 2013. Joel had come to Langford Auditorium at Vanderbilt University in Nashville for an evening of questions and answers and a little music with students.
Michael Pollack was 18 and in his first year at Vanderbilt. He had grown up on Long Island, just like Joel. He had played Billy Joel songs ever since he started playing piano. As a teenager he had even played in a Billy Joel cover band and performed with Richie Cannata, Joel’s longtime saxophone player.
When he heard Joel was coming to campus, he made a plan. He and his roommate showed up early to get seats that were not the closest, but the ones right in Joel’s line of sight. When Joel started looking for questions, Michael’s friends all pointed at him.

“OK”
Joel paused. Then he said, a little reluctantly, “OK.”
Michael walked up to the grand piano. The two of them spent about 15 seconds talking through the arrangement. Then Michael started to play, and Billy Joel started to sing.
“From there, it was just foggy,” Michael said later. “I just started playing. I had practised it a little bit thinking maybe I’d get the chance to go up. I kind of lost myself playing.”
When the song ended, the room erupted, and Joel turned to the crowd.
“That’s Michael Pollack. Remember that name,” he said. “Guy’s got chops!” Then he gave the students some advice: “Take a chance.”
Michael told him he was a Long Islander too. Then he walked back to his seat. “It was probably the greatest moment of my life, up to date,” he said.
Twenty million views later
A video of the moment went online. For a month, it quietly picked up views. Then, in March 2013, news sites found it and it exploded. Within 24 hours, Michael was in New York to appear on NBC’s Today show. By his own count, more than 20 million people watched the clip in its different versions.
The video did something even bigger. It helped him land a music publishing deal while he was still a student. After he graduated, he moved to Los Angeles and started writing songs for other artists.

Remember that name
Billy Joel was right.
Michael Pollack went on to co-write Maroon 5’s hit “Memories” and Justin Bieber’s “Ghost.” He has written for Beyoncé, Selena Gomez, Katy Perry, Kelly Clarkson and many more. In 2022, BMI named him its Pop Songwriter of the Year.
Then, in 2023, he co-wrote Miley Cyrus’s “Flowers.” It went straight to number one, broke Spotify’s record for the most streams in a single week, and won the Grammy for Record of the Year.
It all started with a freshman who raised his hand and asked the Piano Man for a chance.
Watch the moment Billy Joel said yes in the video above.
Photos via Wikimedia Commons: Billy Joel by David Shankbone (CC BY 3.0); Michael Pollack by Johnjohn2024 (CC BY-SA 4.0); Billy Joel 1973 press photo, Columbia Records (public domain); Billy Joel in 2008 by jeaneem (CC BY 2.0).
More stories you might love
Johnny Carson Asked The Audience If Anyone Played Piano. This Guy Raised His Hand, And His Life Forever Changed
He Was Hiding Out in a Los Angeles Piano Bar Under Another Name. The Regulars Became “Piano Man”
A Cell Phone Salesman Told the Judges He Wanted to Sing Opera. They Looked Doubtful. Then He Began to Sing