Neil Diamond Kept the Secret Behind “Sweet Caroline” for Almost 40 Years. It Began With a Little Girl, Her Pony and a Name That Wouldn’t Fit

Advertisement

Bum, bum, bum.

If you have ever been to a ball game, a wedding or a pub at closing time, you have probably shouted it at the top of your lungs.

But for almost 40 years, the man who wrote “Sweet Caroline” would not tell anyone who Caroline was. And when he finally did, the answer turned out to be two different women.

A young Neil Diamond sings into a microphone on The Ed Sullivan Show.
A young Neil Diamond sings “Sweet Caroline” on The Ed Sullivan Show. Image: official Ed Sullivan Show video.

One song short

In 1969, Neil Diamond was in Memphis, Tennessee, to record at American Sound Studio with producer Chips Moman.

In those days, a singer usually recorded three songs in a three-hour session. Neil needed one more for the next morning, and he didn’t have it.

So he sat down in his hotel room the night before and wrote it.

“That song was like a lucky gift that I got,” he told Billboard in 2018. “It came to me when I needed it desperately. I was about to go hungry, I had a new baby, all kinds of things that had counted on this record.”

A photo he never forgot

The melody came quickly. The trouble was the name. He needed one with three syllables to fit the tune.

For years, he had carried a picture in his head. It was a photo he had seen in a magazine of a little girl: Caroline Kennedy, daughter of President John F. Kennedy.

“It was a picture of a little girl dressed to the nines in her riding gear, next to her pony,” he remembered. “It was such an innocent, wonderful picture, I immediately felt there was a song in there.”

He had written her name down years earlier. Now, in that Memphis hotel room, he tried it. “Sweet Caroline.” It fit perfectly.

President Kennedy watches Caroline and John Jr. with their pony Macaroni outside the White House.
President Kennedy with Caroline, John Jr. and their pony, Macaroni, at the White House. Photo: White House / Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

The secret he kept

The song came out that summer and climbed to number four on the Billboard chart. It was his biggest hit up to then.

People soon guessed it might be about Caroline Kennedy. Neil wouldn’t say.

Then, in 2007, Caroline Kennedy turned 50. Neil sang “Sweet Caroline” for her birthday party by satellite, and afterwards he finally told the story.

“I’ve never discussed it with anybody before, intentionally,” he told the Associated Press. “I thought maybe I would tell it to Caroline when I met her someday.” He said he had worried she might be embarrassed, but “she seemed to be struck by it and really, really happy.”

The twist

That should have been the end of it. But in 2014, on NBC’s Today show, Neil added a surprise.

The song, he said, was really about his wife at the time, Marcia. He just couldn’t make her name fit.

“I needed a three-syllable name,” he explained. “The song was about my wife at the time, her name was Marsha, and I couldn’t get a ‘Marsha’ rhyme.”

So a little girl on a pony gave him the name, and his wife gave him the feeling. Music writers have pointed out that Neil and Marcia didn’t actually marry until December 1969, months after the song came out, so only he really knows how the pieces fit together.

Ed Sullivan shakes hands with Neil Diamond on stage.
Ed Sullivan congratulates Neil Diamond after his performance. Image: official Ed Sullivan Show video.

How a love song became everybody’s song

For years, “Sweet Caroline” was just one of Neil’s many hits. Then, in 1997, the Boston Red Sox started playing it at Fenway Park late in games. Before long it was a tradition in the middle of the eighth inning, with the whole ballpark singing along.

Today it is played at sports grounds around the world, from American football to soccer in Britain. Frank Sinatra and Elvis Presley both recorded it. In 2019, the Library of Congress added Neil’s recording to the National Recording Registry, the list of sounds worth keeping forever.

Neil sang it at nearly every concert for almost 50 years, until he stopped touring in 2018 after he was diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease.

Neil Diamond performs on stage with his guitar in 2011.
Neil Diamond in concert in 2011. Photo: Eva Rinaldi / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0.

Not bad for a song written in one night in a hotel room, because a singer was one song short.

Watch a young Neil Diamond sing it on The Ed Sullivan Show in the video above.

Images: frames from the official Ed Sullivan Show video (above); Caroline and John Kennedy Jr. with Macaroni, White House photo (public domain) via Wikimedia Commons; Neil Diamond in 2011 by Eva Rinaldi via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0).

SharePost